Posted on

Down, Down, Down: Energy Prices in the 2010s

By Evelyn Teel

A previous blog post highlighted the shale gas revolution as arguably the most significant energy-related development of the previous decade (you can find the post here: In this article, we will discuss another trend that was significant in the 2010s – declining energy prices.

Natural Gas Prices 

One major effect of the shale gas revolution has been that energy prices in the United States have dropped. In particular, natural gas prices have dropped precipitously as new supply has come online. Prices are significantly lower than they were in 2010 generally, and nearing a third of what they were in January 2010 specifically. Please see the graph below, which shows monthly average natural gas prices at the Henry Hub. 

Superimposing a best-fit linear trend line (in red on the graph below) shows just how dramatic the decade-long decline in prices has been. A few peaks and valleys along the way can obscure the overall change, but the trend line shows that prices are approaching half of what they were in 2010. 

The Forward Curve

The above graphs illustrate that natural gas prices are significantly lower today than they were a decade ago. Equally notable is the change in the forward curve over the past decade. The forward curve represents the market’s expectation of natural gas prices from one month to five years, and even longer, into the future. Below is the 60-month forward curve as of July 9, 2010. The trend was upward sloping, meaning that the market expected prices to continue to rise, with prices ranging from $4.58/mmBtu up to $6.61 per mmBtu.

In the graph below, the natural gas forward curve as of January 21, 2020 has been added. The trend line of this 60-month forward curve is very nearly flat. This means the market expects prices to stay fairly level with prices fluctuating very modestly, between $1.89 per mmBtu and $2.81 per mmBtu.

Electricity Prices

Though less significantly than natural gas prices, electricity prices have likewise fallen. The graph below shows average annual day-ahead electricity prices in PJM. Though there were a few price jumps along the way, the trend over the past decade was that prices declined. Compared to prices in 2010, prices in 2019 were down approximately $20 per MWh.

Historically, natural gas has often been the marginal generation source called upon to produce electricity, meaning that natural gas generation often sets the price for electricity.  While the relationship between natural gas and electricity prices changes over time, the correlation has generally been strong. Also note, that though electricity prices in the wholesale market have fallen, utility distribution charges have been on the rise, and this has generally offset reductions in the cost of electricity generation on customers’ bills. For more information on the evolving relationship between natural gas and electricity prices, please see several of our previous blog posts:

Natural Gas and Electricity Are Parting Ways – Part 1

Natural Gas and Electricity Are Parting Ways – Part 2

Separate Paths – Part 1

Separate Paths – Part 2


With shale gas production projected to increase for the foreseeable future; the US expected to continue expanding as an exporter of liquified natural gas (LNG); greater emphasis on economic discipline (profitability over singular focus on reserve additions) by E&P companies; and the electricity fuel mix continuing to change based on both economics and technical advances that allow increasing renewables into the mix, it will be interesting to see how energy prices respond in the coming decade.

Interested in locking in today’s low energy prices? Please call or email us to discuss your options.

The Avalon Advantage – Visit our website at, call us at 888-484-8096, or email us at

Please feel free to share this article.  If you do, please email or post the web link.  Unauthorized copying, retransmission, or republication is prohibited.

All images copyright 2020 Avalon Energy® Services LLC

Copyright 2020 by Avalon Energy® Services LLC

Posted on

Are Crude Oil and Natural Gas Reconciling?

Crude oil prices have dropped 38% since June for two reasons.  Shale oil production in the US Bakken, Eagle Ford, and Permian basins has increased dramatically – by more than 4 million barrels per day since 2008.  At the same time, worldwide demand for crude oil has declined as a result of slowing economies in China and Europe.

Starting in January 2012, the US crude oil benchmark, West Texas Intermediate (WTI), bounced around $100/Bbl (dollars per barrel), rose above $105/Bbl in June this summer, and is now trading below $65/Bbl.  Natural gas prices fell below $2.00/mmBtu (dollars per million British Thermal Units) during April of 2012, rose above $6/mmBtu during the Polar Vortex during January of this year, and have since fallen below $4.00/mmBtu.

The graph below presents crude oil and natural gas prices on an energy equivalent basis in common units of $/mmBtu.  Starting in January 2012, crude oil bounced around $17/mmBtu, rose above $18/mmBtu in June this summer, and is now trading below $12/mmBtu.

We reported previously on the once wide gap between crude oil and natural gas energy equivalent prices:  Crude Oil and Natural Gas Get a Divorce and Crude Oil and Natural Gas Move To Different Hemispheres.

During April 2014, crude oil reached more than nine times the energy equivalent price of natural gas.  That ratio is now 2.8X.  The graph below shows how this ratio has fallen over the last three years.

While crude oil prices and natural gas prices exhibit little correlation, crude oil prices are highly correlated with fuel oil and diesel prices.  Implications of a declining crude oil to natural gas price ratio include:

  • As natural gas prices spike in pipeline capacity constrained markets this winter, it may be more economical to use fuel oil for power generation than natural gas.
  • The economics associated with converting residential fuel oil furnaces to natural gas become less compelling.
  • The economics associated with converting diesel or gasoline fueled vehicles to compressed natural gas or electricity will worsen, and the payback period associated with existing conversions will be extended further out in time.
  • US liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports will become less competitive in overseas markets where natural gas prices are contractually tied to crude oil prices.
  • Petrochemical facilities that can use both crude oil and natural gas as feedstock may switch more and more to crude oil.

It now appears that crude oil and natural gas may be moving back to the same hemisphere and, possibly, reconciling.

The Avalon Advantage – Visit our website at, call us at 888-484-8096, or email us at


Please feel free to share this article.  If you do, please email or post the web link.  Unauthorized copying, retransmission, or republication is prohibited.

Copyright 2014 by Avalon Energy® Services LLC

Posted on

Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG)

The development of a liquefied natural gas export trade was identified in a previous article as an influence that would put upward pressure on natural gas prices. To follow is an overview of where the US liquefied natural gas markets have been and where they may be headed. But first, what is liquefied natural gas?

At atmospheric temperature and pressure, natural gas (methane, CH4) exists in a gaseous state. When cooled to minus 260 degrees F, methane condenses into a liquid state. This liquid form of methane takes up approximately 1/600th the volume of methane in gaseous form and is known as liquefied natural gas or LNG. From a commercial perspective, the distribution of natural gas is limited to the pipeline network natural gas can be delivered into, whereas, because of its much greater energy density (70% that of gasoline), LNG can be transported in cryogenic tanks over long distances by specialized ocean going vessels.

How big is the LNG market in the US? The above graph shows the volume of LNG imports and exports into and out of the US over the twenty-six year period of time spanning 1985 through 2010. [Click on graphs to enlarge.] LNG imports became significant around the turn of the century, peaked at 770 billion cubic feet (BCF) during 2007 and then fell off as natural gas prices dropped precipitously during 2008. During 2010, the US imported 431 BCF of LNG. LNG export volumes have been minor, averaging 58 BCF per year.

During 2011, the slide in LNG imports continued as shown in the graph above, totaling 350 BCF (estimate).

How have LNG imports compared to overall US consumption? Consumption of natural gas in the US rose dramatically from 4,971 BCF during 1949 to 22,101 BCF during 1972, after which it fell to 16,221 BCF during 1986 and then rose to 23,775 BCF during 2010. Over the last 26 years, LNG imports as a share of total US consumption peaked at 3.3% during 2007.

How have LNG import volumes behaved compared to US natural gas prices? These two variables are presented together on the above graph. It is hard to tell much from this graph. We took the above data and lagged (shifted forward in time) the natural gas prices one month at a time and calculated the correlation between LNG import volumes and US natural gas prices.

The correlation is highest at 53.8% with a 19 month lag as shown on the left graph above. The graph to the right shows the same volume and pricing data with prices shifted forward 19 months.

So far we have looked at LNG import volumes. What about LNG export volumes? Since 1985, LNG export volumes have been minor, averaging 58 BCF per year. In the current low natural gas price environment (the February NYMEX futures contract settled at $2.32 on 1/19/12) this will change.

There are twelve LNG import terminals in the US (see table at end of article). Nine applications have been submitted to the Department of Energy seeking permits that would allow facilities to export LNG. Two permit requests have been conditionally approved. One is Cheniere Energy in Sabine, Louisiana and the other is Dominion’s Cove Point facility on the Chesapeake Bay.

Exports of 6 BCF per day, or 2,190 BCF per year, are equivalent to 9.8% of current US natural gas consumption. The nine facilities that have applied for export permits, together, seek to ship about 14 BCF of natural gas per day. If they are all successful, exports would grow to 5,110 BCF per year, or the equivalent of 22% of current US natural gas consumption.

This is a stunning change in the US LNG trade and will certainly create upward pressure on natural gas prices in the US. The range of estimates of the price increase impact of each BCF per day of exports, according to ICF, are from $0.02 to $0.30 per mmBtu. EIA’s estimates for each BCF of exports range from $0.07 to $0.17 per mmBtu.

The Avalon Advantage – Visit our website at, call us at 888-484- 8096, or email us at

Copyright 2012 by Avalon Energy® Services LLC